Preschool Jitters: Crystal kids in a linear environment?

Yesterday was Monday, which meant Lucas had gymnastics class at the Y. Here's a little snapshot of our 4th class:

  • The children are moving through an obstacle course in a counterclockwise direction, moving from one obstacle to the next. Lucas is sampling obstacles willy-nilly, selecting the ones he likes and refusing to try others. (After the 3rd class last week, I gave up trying to get him to go in the same direction as the rest of the kids, and just focused on keeping him from bonking into anyone.)
  • Miss Kelsie excitedly says, "Lucas, do you want to try a forward roll?" Lucas answers, "No, I don't." He walks away.
  • It's parachute time. After refusing to participate for the first two weeks of class, today he manages to make it half-way through before losing interest and wandering off to inspect the hula hoops.
  • The rest of the kids are jumping joyfully into the "marshmallow pit" (a big squishy "lake" filled with soft foam cubes). Lucas is still suspicious and refuses to join them.
  • He kills it on the trampoline, though. Saving grace.

Everyone else seemed to be following directions. Everyone else seemed eager to cooperate with Miss Kelsie and try the trick of the week. Everyone else liked the marshmallow pit. How could a kid not love the marshmallow pit?

This is just the beginning of learning to handle ourselves among "everyone else." What I mean by this, specifically, is that it's the beginning of me learning to handle the fact that Lucas is probably not going to go with the flow like everyone else. I am constantly reminding myself that this isn't a competition. I have to bite my lip to keep from urging him to look at the other kids and do what they do. And even though I'm conscious of the inherent gifts of his nonlinear, intuitive mind, I still forget sometimes that this also means he's not going to do things in an A to B to C manner.

As with anything in life, it seems there is a careful balance to be found between respecting his way of being and giving him free reign to do as he pleases. In gymnastics class, I'm still there with him to say, "No, you don't have to try a cartwheel today, but Miss Kelsie would probably appreciate it if you said, 'No thank you, I'm not ready yet.'" I'm still there with him when he wanders away from the parachute to let him know it's okay if he doesn't want to do the parachute activities, but it's not okay to run off and join the cute girls doing floor routines in the other class.

I know he feels respected by my gentle redirections. I know his preferences are being honored, and at the same time, reasonable boundaries are being reinforced. That's because I know him, I love him, and I respect who he is.

When (if) I send him to preschool in September, who will know him, love him and respect him enough to walk that just-right balance with him? Surely, I can't be alone in this fear. I worry that in someone else's eyes, Lucas' gifts will be seen as shortcomings; that his strength of character will be seen as willfulness; that his nonlinear, creative thinking will be seen as an inability to follow simple directions; that his delightful energy and talkativeness will be interpreted as hyperactivity.

I worry that he'll get in trouble for being who he is. And I won't be there to reframe it for him or for his teacher.

No one wants to be "That Mom" who shows up at school telling the teachers how special her child is and how they should adjust the way they do their job with her particular child.

But …

I think I'm going to have to be that mom. When I weigh the costs of my embarrassment at possibly being singled out as the crazy one with the costs of Lucas being misunderstood and internalizing that there's something wrong with him, it's just not worth it to stay quiet. He's just a tiny little guy. I'm the mom. I'm his best advocate. If I don't stand up for him, who will?

Here's my plan in a nutshell: I'm going to talk with his teacher before school starts and explain what I do at home that works well for him (gentle redirection and keeping his busy mind engaged), and what doesn't work well for him (punishment, shaming, harsh voice). I'm going to request that she please try to use the former approach, if she doesn't already do so, or else she'll be witness to some major meltdowns. I'll certainly go over his peanut allergy with her. I may or may not go into some of his other sensitivities, depending on her receptivity. I may need to take a gradual approach, starting with the most important and obvious things, and working the rest in later.

And if I run into a brick wall with this conversation, well … then he doesn't go to preschool just yet. Or I find another place. This is the beginning of some really important decisions we'll need to make on Lucas' behalf. I'll do what it takes to make sure it's the right fit for him. It's the least I can do.


 

6 comments:

Debs July 22, 2009 5:57 AM  

You could have been talking about my son, then, when you described how Lucas is in his class. R is the same - he does not respond well at all to any situation where it's, "now we all have to stop doing that and do this" all the time, and I can see his point of view because I tend to think in the same way - "WHY do I have to do this thing when that thing over there is much more interesting to me?!" He likes to go with the flow of his own instincts, which is why we don't do any kind of structured activities at the moment. I don't know when we will next - it will be whenever R is ready for that, it may be next year, it may be never - who knows.

I knew before I had any children that I would home educate, but seeing how R responds to that kind of "school" or "class" way of thinking has just cemented in my mind that home education is far and away the best thing for him. I'm not saying that's what you should do of course - that's a decision that only you and your family can make, and children can sometimes flourish in a "class" environment.

But I think you're right, if you do send him to preschool, you *will* have to be "that mom" and more power to you - I think more people should be "that mom"! Don't be afraid of what anyone else thinks. You have absolutely the right attitude - Lucas is relying on you to look out for his interests, and no teacher, no matter how nice or well trained, can have that instinct for him like you have.

Good luck with whatever you decide. :) xx

Alexis July 22, 2009 6:55 AM  

Debs~ Thank you SO MUCH for sharing your perspective on this. I feel supported and empowered by your words. Home education has always been an option for us. We're hoping to send him to our local Waldorf school when the time comes, but with the full intention of watching carefully to see if it's the right fit. If it isn't, then homeschooling is our second choice. My intuition tells me we'll likely end up doing the latter anyway. Thank you again for your encouragement and support! I appreciate it!
Cheers!
Alexis

Stacy (mama-om) July 22, 2009 6:57 AM  

We didn't do preschool.... or school at all! :) We're homeschooling!

Homeschooling has had its own challenges, but I cannot imagine my kids spending most of their time in a school or class environment.

However, now, at age six, my older son has really been enjoying the classes and camps he's participated in this summer.

I hope you find the right balance for you and Lucas -- I am sure you will. :)

Best,
Stacy

spirityoga July 22, 2009 7:08 AM  

I can certainly relate to your post. Thanks for sharing!

A timely post because I've been thinking a lot about schooling lately. We have A. registered in a Montessori-based preschool starting in January, but just one day a week. I guess we'll take it from there and see how it goes.

mommymystic July 25, 2009 7:30 AM  

Alexis - you've hit the nail on the head with this one. Of my three, one of the twins is very much like what you describe here. The other two are strong-willed, but more interested in group activities. The twins just started a gym class also, and one does not really want to do anything yet - at least not while the other kids are doing it. It's a fine line, trying to not just enforce conformity blindly, but also encouraging respect for others in the group (i.e. explaining that you can't just walk up the slide, when everyone else is trying to come down it, etc.) Also, I do believe that to reach their potential they need to understand how to function in society - I have know too many 'spiritual' people that seem to function outside society because they are fearful of it, and I don't want that to happen either.

All three go to a Montessori preschool, and the self-directed nature of that so far has been perfect for all of them. So I think it really is about having the right environment and learning style in preschool, and of course the teacher is key. My eldest starts public kindergarten this Fall though, so we will see how that goes. Of all of mine, she is probably the most social and adaptable, so I think it will work for her, but am not so sure about the twins.

Alexis July 27, 2009 10:46 AM  

Spirityoga~ Good luck with the Montessori program. I am beginning to think that might be a good approach for Lucas down the road.

Stacy~ I am leaning strongly toward "home-preschooling". A) The money we'd spend to have someone else teach him - when I am more than confident in both my teaching abilities and my knowledge of my own son - is beginning to seem ridiculous. B) In thinking more deeply about why we send our children to preschool - to prepare them for a school environment - it doesn't make sense to rush his precious childhood freedom in the name of learning to stand in lines and take turns. That said ...

Lisa ~ I appreciate your point about our children learning to function in society so they can reach their full potential. That is the fine line we walk, isn't it? If we want our children to help create a new society that isn't a repeat of the current one, they can't be completely immersed in the current structures. They need to be just enough versed in the current paradigm to be able to help transition it into a newer version.

For me, this seems to mean that I need to wait a while to "dip" Lucas into the current structures, and then, when he's ready, find an option that allows him to connect to the current and also stretch the paradigm. (Sorry for the jargon - I can't seem to help myself.) That may be Montessori at first, and then Waldorf. Or it may be homeschooling with a lot of extracurricular opportunities. We'll take it as it comes.

Thanks everyone for your thoughtful ideas on this. It has helped me clarify my thoughts.

Cheers!
Alexis

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Comments

Followers

Blog Archive

Search

Loading...