I am Three Again, and I Don’t Like it One Bit!

I love other people's three-year-olds.

Mine, I'm ready to sell to the gypsies. Just kidding.

Kind of.

This post is a public attempt at learning from my current and intense frustration with my skills as a mother of a strong-willed, too-smart-for-his-Elmo-undies, newly baby-talking, and utterly contrary three-year-old son. I have lost my perspective, and I'm hoping it's only temporarily misplaced, because I am now engaging with him as a fellow three-year-old, and I know this can't be a good idea.

There are layers of learning here, and in the end, I'm sure it will all boil down to acceptance and surrender, because that's what always seems to be left for me when the rest has evaporated.

But first, may I vent? Just a little? I feel like I'm going to explode if I don't. I'll limit it to my top three annoyances.

Baby-talk

This boy who was speaking at one, and who can tell complete stories that can actually be understood by strangers is now using lispy baby-talk as his primary mode of communication. Here I think I'm sending him to preschool as the youngest in his class to challenge him and expose him to other kids he can learn from, and he comes back emulating someone's baby-talk. Ugh!

I made the mistake of letting him know it bugs me. Now he doesn't buy my fake nonchalance and talks like this all the time. Asking him to use his big-boy voice has no effect.

Contrariness

I know it's his job to be contrary at this age. He's learning to exercise his power and will. I used to say this to other parents as a way of offering a comforting perspective; to depersonalize the behavior a bit. I now know how annoying this is. It doesn't help me one bit to know this.

Everything is a battle these days. Mainly, the battles surround those things he ultimately has control over: eating and voiding. (Since letting go of his naps, the sleeping isn't an issue anymore.) He wants snacks instead of meals; he wants banana bread all day long and throws a screaming fit when I don't give it to him; he looks at what's for dinner and then walks away if he doesn't like it. "Fine! Don't eat then!" my inner three-year-old snaps at him.

One recent way of showing his contrariness has been to deliberately poop and pee in his pants - while we're home with a readily available bathroom. After a few rounds of this, my husband resorted to threatening to take away his guitar and stereo privileges if he made that choice again. The "accidents" stopped. They weren't accidents.

I've resorted to carrying him, kicking and screaming, into his room for time-outs when he starts in with one of his tantrums. I can't even handle time-ins right now.

I offer him reasonable ways of exercising his budding power, but it seems it's not enough for him. I worry that he won't be satisfied until he has reached world domination.

Clinginess

Lucas (in high-pitched, whiny baby-talk): Will you go to da bafwoom wif me?

Me: What? You know how to go by yourself.

Lucas: But I want your attention.

Me: You've had my full attention all morning! We just finished doing puzzles, reading books, and coloring. Can you just do this one thing by yourself, please?

Lucas: No! (favorite word) I want you to go with me! (Now commanding) Go with me, Mommy!

For crying out loud! The more attention I give him, it seems, the more he wants. What happened to the independence of the twos?

Since I told you I'd limit it to three things, I guess that's it for the venting. On to the learning.

Oh – except the colds! I have to add one more thing! The colds! He's been mildly sick six times in the last eight weeks, throwing a giant, frustrating wrench into any semblance of routine I might be trying to uphold. How do I maintain consistency in the midst of a constant barrage of cancellations and exceptions due to illness? How do people manage with more than one child, assuming they don't all get sick at the same time? I have no more sympathy left. The coughing and the runny noses are only further irritants in a swirling mass of annoyance.

Back to the learning …

The best way for me to get to the learning is to examine what I'm feeling. First, I feel angry at Lucas for not being who I want him to be. That's the honest truth, even if it's not the most enlightened thing to say. While I'm in this kind of victim mode, I want to tell him, "You were lucky enough to get an awesome mom and I'm doing everything in my power to do right by you, and here you are throwing it in my face with this ridiculous behavior. I don't deserve this. I deserve a brilliant, peaceful, delightful child who is a joy to be with, AND … you should be healthy what with the three organic, home-cooked meals I make for you every day, and your healthy, organic, low-in-sugar, dairy-free snacks, and your stress-free lifestyle. What is up with your immune system anyway?!"

So who's the ridiculous one? Yes, it's me. Writing this out is helping me see this all clearly for what it is: ridiculous and unreasonable expectations.

I also feel angry at myself for not being the mom I want to be. The self-talk goes kind of like this: I should know how to handle this better. I should not be getting angry. I should be more patient, more resourceful, more creative, more understanding. I should be preparing only healing Ayurvedic foods for Lucas so he can have balanced Pitta.* After a four-day retreat away from my family, I should not want to immediately run away again for about a month.

Should, should, should. Again … ridiculous and unreasonable expectations. (And really, who doesn't wish for a month's vacation free of family responsibilities? Okay, so I might not last more than two weeks. Three, tops.)

What else do I feel? I feel alone and a bit confused. I'm not really sure where to turn for advice, since my approach to parenting has already veered well away from any sort of mainstream philosophies. I want someone, maybe the Super Nanny, to give me the answer, and yet I don't trust the methodology that will probably be suggested. I have a feeling I already have the answers I need to handle this better, but I'm just not able to access them right now.


Do I re-examine every boundary and chuck the ones that are borderline unnecessary? Do I say yes more often, right from the get-go? "Sure, you can have nothing but cheerios and apple juice all day."


Or, do I create more boundaries? More routines? Maybe Monday is turkey sandwich day for lunch and it's always turkey sandwich day on Monday and therefore, there will be no further expectations of anything other than turkey sandwiches on Mondays. That kind of thing? It sounds a bit insane to plan things out to that degree, but Waldorf has been very effective with this sort of daily and weekly rhythm.

I suppose a bit more time and perspective will help me tap into the inspiration I need to get to the answers that are just right for us. That, and some meditations that aren't interrupted by a million intruding thoughts like they have been lately. From that perspective, it's no surprise that I'm feeling so out of whack.

Finally, I feel really, really humbled – which I think is a good thing. I know that if I'm to effectively help and support other parents, I have to keep growing, as a parent and as a person. That means that by necessity, it's NOT going to be easy all the time. I have to come up against these challenges in order to deeply wrestle with what I believe and what is actually working on a practical level as I raise my son.

In summary, the learning turned out to be about acceptance and surrender, after all; Accepting what is, instead of pushing for what should be; Accepting that I'm not perfect and Lucas isn't perfect, and that's just the way it is with everyone; Surrendering expectations; Surrendering my ego, so that I can grow and learn. I think this awareness will help me to be less reactive and more thoughtful. Already, I feel a shift for the better.

And so, in this openness, I invite you to share your thoughts and suggestions. And if you can recommend a good boarding preschool … kidding, kidding.

Cheers!

Alexis

*I just started checking into Ayurvedic cooking in the last couple of weeks. It looks way too complicated, but if I took the time to learn it, I'm sure we'd all be pictures of glowing health. Or not. Who knows?

7 comments:

Anonymous November 21, 2009 9:35 AM  

Alexis, I have a few suggestions to offer from my background in early childhood development. Regarding meal choices, this will go against your own widsom as an adult, but give in to his wish if he only wants cheerios and apple juice all day. This is a phase and will soon pass!!! If all he eats are these two items, he will get bored very quickly and choose something else to eat on his own terms. Trust me, he will not eat the same two things for more than a few days, or perhaps a week. Let this phase live itself out naturally. He will not drastically do harm to his body he fails to get a balanced diet for a few days.

Secondly, regarding the potty training frustrations, make Lucas accept responsibility for cleaning up his messes. He if poops or pees in his pants when you know he is fully capable of using the potty, he is clearly exercising his own control. He needs to accept ownership of the consequences. Allow him to help with the clean up by washing his underwear in a small plastic tub that he could put on the floor or on a low table. The Montessori classroom teaches washing clothes within the Practical Life curriculum. Children as young as 3 years old are taught how to wash clothing. Let him wash his clothes and see how much work it is.

I hope my suggestions give you a few alternatives to ponder as you decide how to handle these new challenges in your life.

Alicia

Stacy (Mama-Om) November 22, 2009 5:57 PM  

Oh, Alexis!! I feel you. I had a new baby when Orlando turned three... and my goodness I was totally blindsided by my own limits and sudden taking things personally. In retrospect, I can see how the shift into three is all about moving from the body into the emotions. Caring for my newborn and toddler was very physically intensive and I could do it, not without problem but certainly without feeling so out of my depth. But when Orlando turned three (and I was also caring for an infant), suddenly things felt very emotional, and to be honest, I found myself not having the ability to hold his emotions. I wanted to push him away (as I was pushed away when I showed emotion when I was three). This was so heart-breaking for me, and like you, I wanted to find our through it.

So, THANK GOODNESS for awareness, right?

There is a lot of talk in the AP and Positive-Discipline circles that three is the new two. That kids raised respectfully don't go through the "terrible twos" but most parents report feeling overwhelmed at three. No one could really explain why, but I came up with my theory above.

Some stuff to read (if you haven’t already)...

-Your Three Year Old, Ames and Ilg (not for discipline but for developmental info)
-Kids Are Worth It, Coloroso
-How to Talk So Kids Will Listen
-Hold On to Your Kids, Nuefeld
and a short article on counterwill, http://www.gordonneufeld.com/course_counterwill.php

Oh, I also wanted to say that it is very common for three year olds to "regress" to infancy. Or rather, they are revisiting infancy as they make a huge developmental leap away from it. I made this a game with Orlando... he just wanted to "play" baby. [In fact, he did something very similar today on our date, pretending to be a "baby" elephant who needed its mama to guide it with its trunk. It continually got lost and went the wrong way and wanted mama to gently guide him. I did get a little impatient with the game but it also really touched me -- he was setting up safe place to wander around and make mistakes and always return to mama.]

It can definitely be hard, and the desire to resist connection can be intense and persistent, but I would encourage you, in every way, to maintain connection with Lucas through this time.

BTW, has he already started preschool? That could also be part of his needed to return to a younger time -- he can perceive how he is moving away from that time in his life and he wants to feel safe as he grows. Have you read "Magical Child" by Joseph Chilton Pearce? It seems right up your alley but one of the main things I remember about it is the idea of a matrix, and of how the child must complete each phase before moving on and how they know they're complete is by revisiting where they've been.

Okay, this is a very LONG and RAMBLY comment... I am feeling for you and am so glad you shared of your struggle so freely.

Blessings,
Stacy

Alexis November 23, 2009 7:22 AM  

Alicia~ Thank you so much for your suggestions! I'll give them a try and see how it goes. I appreciate it!

Stacy~ Thanks for so beautifully addressing my need for connection here. It is amazing how much it helps to know I'm not alone and that someone else deeply understands.

How interesting about three being the new two! I certainly found that to be my experience, but since I'm not in any circles, I didn't know this was a new and common theme.

I certainly relate to having all of this emotion trigger my own experiences of being pushed away at three. Yes - Thank goodness for awareness!

The book recs are great and appreciated. Thanks!I have read some, including your link on counterwill, but I'm due for a re-read - obviously.

He did start preschool in Sept, two mornings a week, and that is when this all started. Maybe it is just revisiting where he's been since he's completed that last phase. (I need to read Magical Child again, too. Love him! I heard him speak in person and he is absolutely amazing!)

Thanks, thanks, thanks for your support and suggestions. I so appreciate them and appreciate you!
Cheers!

Anonymous November 25, 2009 4:19 PM  

Hi~
We just finished taking the Redirecting Children's Behaviour class with Susie Walton at Indigo Village, and over half the parents in there were inspired to come because of their 3 year olds! Susie's book is available in the waiting area, if you want to flip through it, see if you like it?? Wishing you good luck!!

Alexis November 27, 2009 10:08 AM  

Anon~ So how did you like Susie's class? I've heard great things about it. I have skimmed the book. It looks good, although I didn't find anything there that I didn't already know - now, whether I remember to practice it regularly or not is a different matter.

Cheers!
Alexis

Lisa (Mommy Mystic) December 9, 2009 1:35 PM  

Alexis - just getting caught up here, and could totally relate to this post. Not to one-up you, but I have 2 three year olds right now!! (So there!! My not-so-subtle beg for sympathy.) And I can definitely relate to this. My daughter has reverted to baby-talk, and my son pulls the 'help me' on absolutely everything, from going to the bathroom to getting a cup of water to putting on his socks. But heaven forbid I should help him when he doesn't ask - then he throws a tantrum about that!
It really is too funny. I don't have any advice, you've gotten great book suggestions from Stacy. I will have to check out Magical Child too, I have not read it. Just letting you know, I hear you!

Alexis December 10, 2009 9:47 AM  

Hi Lisa - Yes, I was thinking about you with the twins. You are definitely deserving of some sympathy! Thanks for the sisterhood. You're right that it's kind of funny - except that when it's this relentless, it loses its humor, doesn't it?

I finished reading Your Three Year Old - and discovered this is exactly what to expect with about a three and a half year old, so that was some consolation. I'm also partway through Hold on to Your Kids and it's provided some profound insights into how my change in behavior toward Lucas as he's gotten older has contributed to some of this frustration. Thanks, Stacy, for the book recs!!!

Cheers!
Alexis

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Comments

Followers

Blog Archive

Search

Loading...