I've started to insist that Lucas take care of a few more things by himself. At three, his motor skills are sufficiently developed to do basic daily tasks like get dressed, make his bed, clear the table, and wipe his butt. I'd been avoiding this delegation of responsibility for a variety of stupid reasons:
- He was asking me to do these things for him, and I was under the misguided notion that I was building our bond by saying yes unless there was a really compelling reason to say no. (It didn't occur to me until recently that personal responsibility and self-confidence could be compelling reasons.)
- I didn't want to add more opportunities for us to lock horns.
- It took him too long and I was impatient.
- I'm better at them. Might as well do them myself.
I read another book.
I know, I know. I need to learn to trust myself and stop looking to experts who don't know my child, but THIS one (Kids are Worth it!, by Barbara Coloroso) was really helpful and here's why: Reading it tripped a little memory switch in my mind, and suddenly I was back in my classroom teaching my second and third graders at Willamette Primary in the '90s. I could see myself empowering them to take responsibility for themselves in everything from homework to personal conflicts. I could see their class meetings, their brainstorming sessions to come up with solutions to classroom problems, their independence, and their confidence. I could clearly see how giving them the space to muddle through things that were initially difficult, while offering just the right amount of encouragement and guidance, resulted in astounding capacity and self-esteem. By half-way through each year, they were practically running the class themselves.
Through my little flash-back, I could see how I was currently robbing my son of this same experience by doing everything for him. The more I helped, the more he needed. The more I said yes, the more he demanded. Mothering him was becoming exhausting and annoying.
I began to insist that Lucas take care of a few more things by himself, while affirming that I knew he could handle it. At first, I did the tasks with him, narrating each step of the process. For example:
"This is how you can lay out your pajamas. You can sit on them here and then slide your legs into the little footies. That's right. Now slide your arms into the armholes. You've got it. Now stand up and zip it up. You did it!"
I narrated this one twice for him, slowly and step by step, before he had it. Sure, it took a lot longer than pulling them on him myself, but now when I say, "It's time to put on your pjs," he goes in his room to put them on by himself, taking up none of my time. Brilliant, isn't it?
I did the same with putting on socks and shoes, making his bed, wiping his bottom, and cleaning up after himself if he'd made a mess. It feels like I've spent the last two weeks doing nothing more than coaching him through these basic tasks. It's been kind of relaxing, actually. It takes a lot less energy to sit and watch him than it does to be lifting, bending, picking up, cleaning up, harping, and complaining.
My mother was over on one of those days and observed, "You seem awfully patient all of a sudden. What changed?" It reminded me of when I was teaching, and people would compliment me on my perceived patience. I would tell them, "Oh no, I'm not patient at all. That's why it's worth it to me to build this independence now, so I don't have to listen to the whining, tattling, or arguing for the rest of the year. That would drive me crazy."
The same holds true for Lucas. It's not patience. It's hedging my bets! It's peacefully accepting the process, and trusting that we're on the right track. I know we're on the right track because the power struggles have almost completely stopped, he's eager to show off his competence, and we're enjoying our time together much more. He's spending his time engaged in meaningful work that's challenging enough to keep him interested, while not frustrating him. This work has taken the place of activities like begging for snacks all day long, arguing with me, throwing temper tantrums, and bugging the cats.
The possibilities for meaningful work are endless! If he happens to splash water on the floor of the bathroom while washing his hands, I say, "There's the towel," and he gets to work wiping it up. If he drops a few crumbs on the floor during snack, I hand him the mini dustpan and broom and he happily practices his sweeping. If he has an accident in his underwear, I say, "Hmm… It looks like you have a problem. What's your plan to solve it?" He says, "I'm going to go change my underwear and put these in the laundry." And then I say, "Sounds good. I know you can handle it." Off he goes.
I love it! I get help and he gains skills and confidence! I think the power struggles have dwindled because he's finding appropriate ways of exercising his power and competence. It seems like such a no-brainer now, but I just couldn't see it before.
Next, I'm going to teach him to cook. That'll save me some time!
*Interesting that this song by the Isley Brothers is one of Lucas' current faves.
8 comments:
interesting! my kids being in a montessori preschool got me focused on self-sufficiency as they are big into that...and it definitely also helps me practice patience and surrender, as it takes forever for the three of them to get their coats and shoes on (for example) by themselves when we need to go somewhere...
however, my son started rebelling against doing things himself awhile back, and after reading your post referencing this i actually relaxed about it and started doing more for him again...my sense is that sometimes it is a power game and sometimes it is about needing my focus...i am still experimenting with this (and part of me says "is this a boy thing - wanting to be served?" because the girls never do it!!!)
anyway, isn't it interesting these different cycles we each go through, i moved towards this as you are moving away from it and visa versa...motherhood really is this constant dance!!!
forgot to mention another variation on your theme - housecleaning!! in montessori the kids help clean the classroom and after coming to pick them up one day and seeing them happily sweeping and cleaning windows, i realized i definitely needed to jump on that!! they love to help me clean (which is not that often, lol)...we will see how long this lasts:-)
Hi Alexis:
Thanks for this. After reading your post, I'm now motivated to teach Moses these things too...
Hi Lisa ~ Dance is such a good word for it. Yes, moving in and out of ways of being with our kiddos. And just as soon as we think we've figured something out, they go and change on us!
I sure hope this "being served" isn't some sort of innate boy thing! I think you're right that sometimes it's a power thing and sometimes it's needing our focus or attention. I find it hard to believe that Lucas, as an only child, is in need of more focused attention from me, but I'm open to that as a possibility.
I suppose flexibility is important. If I hold self-sufficiency as a general expectation and a value, it's still perfectly fine for me to occasionally help him with things he wants help with, especially if he's feeling particularly needy for whatever reason. The challenge is to solidify the expectation before I start making exceptions to it, and not to make exceptions too often. So glad to be having these conversations with you!
Hi Janice ~ You're welcome. As you can see by this exchange here, it's one big experiment, isn't it?
Cheers!
Alexis
Hi Alexis!
I remember you talking about your indepdence-building strategies you used in school when we were leading the YOUers... glad you have been able to reimplement that strategy! :)
Your last two posts reminded me of when I used to read lots and lots of spiritual books, and it seemed like every other one was saying something completely polar opposite. I'd read Abraham-Hicks, about "having it all, attracting things, getting everything you want." I'd be all pumped, but then I'd read The Power of Now or the Tao Te Ching, all about "letting go, embracing nothingness, being unattached to things, not wanting." I would get so frustrated because each book seemed to contradict the others, even the ones I really liked!!
Finally (after a lot of struggle) I realized that it was the back and forth process itself through which I was forging my own personal spiritual path... and in the process learning to synthesize what had at first seemed like opposite or contradictory approaches into a holistic and balanced whole that worked for me.
Anyway, I know its different than parenting (which I know NOTHING about), but thought I'd share what your posts made me think of.
Thanks for continuing to share your stories! Hope to get down to SD soon... would love to see you!! :)
Hey Nick! How great that you chimed in here! Your thoughts about forging your own spiritual path are really insightful. Even the word "forging" is so perfect - I get the image of the blacksmith hammering first one side of ... something iron, and then hammering the other side, back and forth until it all evens out. It's a great way of looking at it - much better than thinking of myself as waffling between one idea or another.
It's really not different from parenting at all. Parenting has turned out to be more of a spiritual challenge than anything else I've ever encountered. I really appreciate you sharing your thoughts. As ever, you and I travel such parallel paths when it comes to spiritual growth. So nice to connect with you here! I'd love to see you when you come to SD!
Cheers!
Alexis
I have to say that this post is right on, Alexis! And it's a lifetime process; I see 18 year olds everyday with whom I engage in similar fashion to help them work towards taking responsibility for themselves. And then there's me, and I need all the constructive engagement I can get in order to help me to help myself! Lifetime....ergo, patience. /masaru
Thanks, Masaru! Yes ... a lifetime process. Did you read my mind? See my next post. Still trying to empower myself. :)
Cheers!
Alexis
Post a Comment